Apple Inc v. SpaceTime3D Inc

W. Karl Renner

Apple challenges a 3D timeline user interface patent, arguing all 19 claims are obvious over the combined teachings of Anthony, Hanggie & Matthews.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
David C McKone	1000+	76%	85%
Frederick C Laney	700+	80%	83%
Hubert C Lorin	100+	56%	91%

Name	Ratings
Apple Inc	L5A
Google LLC	L5A

Name	Ratings
Fish & Richardson	L5A
W. Karl Renner	L5A
Andrew Patrick	L4A
Kenneth Darby	L4C
Usman Khan	L3B
Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP	L5A
Erika H. Arner	L5A
Cory Bell	L5E
Yanyi Liu	L2C
Yinan Liu	L2C
DLA Piper US LLP	L5E
Matthew Satchwell	L5D
Brent K. Yamashita	L5E
Christopher G. Duerden	L1C

Name	Ratings
Jeffer Mangels Butler & Mitchell LLP	L3B
Gregory S. Cordrey	L5A
Fitzsimmons IP Law	L2C
Todd E. Fitzsimmons	L2D