Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v. Neonode Smartphone LLC

W. Karl Renner

Samsung & Apple target touch-and-glide UI patent: multiple prior art references cited for obviousness of 12 claims over known gesture technology.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Christopher L Ogden	300+	65%	80%
Kara L Szpondowski	200+	64%	82%
Michelle N Ankenbrand	200+	50%	81%

Name	Ratings
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5A
Apple Inc	L5A
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5A

Name	Ratings
Lowenstein & Weatherwax LLP	L5A
Kenneth Weatherwax	L4A
Parham Hendifar	L4A
Patrick G. Maloney	L4B
Vinson Lin	L2D
Sunstein Kann Murphy & Timbers LLP	L4E
Bruce D. Sunstein	L4D
Robert M. Asher	L4E
Timothy M. Murphy	L2B
Arne Hans	---- --