PTAB

IPR2020-01026

Walmart Inc v. Caravan Canopy Intl Inc

General

Filed

06/01/20

Institution12/15/20

FWD11/22/21

Close11/22/21

StatusFinal Written Decision

OutcomeUnpatentable

SourceUSPTO

Appeals22-1642

Administrative Patent Judges

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Bart A Gerstenblith	500+	60%	80%
Eric C Jeschke	200+	60%	87%
James J Mayberry	400+	61%	84%

Petitioner

Party

Name	Ratings
Walmart	L2B
Costco Wholesale Corp	L3B
Z-Shade Co Ltd	L2B
Lowe's Home Centers LLC	L2C
Shelterlogic Corp	L1B

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Knobbe Martens	L5A
Kerry S. Taylor	L4A
Andrew M. Douglas	---- --
Kilpatrick	L5A
David A. Reed	L4E
Tyler McAllister	L1C
Neifeld IP Law	L3E
Richard A. Neifeld	L4E
Carmody & Torrance	L1C
Damian K. Gunningsmith	L1D
Brown Wegner LLP	---- --
Winfield J. Brown	---- --

Respondent

Party

Name	Ratings
Caravan Canopy Intl Inc	L1D

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Womble Bond Dickinson	L4B
Kyle W. Kellar	L2E
Jason C. Martone	---- --
Steven French	---- --
SML Avvocati P.C.	L1C
Stephen M. Lobbin	L1C
Joshua Osborn	---- --