BlackBerry Corp v. Uniloc 2017 LLC

W. Karl Renner

BlackBerry challenges a UMTS network patent on 2 obviousness grounds: 3GPP standards & Peisa cited for TFC selection over a min bit rate criteria.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
John F Horvath	300+	77%	93%
Josiah C Cocks	600+	62%	88%
Robert J Weinschenk	600+	54%	86%

Name	Ratings
BlackBerry Corp	L4E
Apple Inc	L5A
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5A
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5A
LG Electronics	L5B

Name	Ratings
Fish & Richardson	L5A
W. Karl Renner	L4A
Roberto J. Devoto	L3A
Ayan Roy-Chowdhury	L2C
Oblon McClelland Maier & Neustadt LLP	L5E
Alexander B. Englehart	L3C
Maier Maier	L2B
Timothy Maier	L2B
Christopher J. Maier	L2B
Mattson IP PLC	L2B
Robert C. Mattson	L4E