Pantech Co Ltd v. Cellular Communications Equipment LLC

Steven B. Kelber

NEC, HTC & LG challenge a mobile security patent: Multiple grounds of anticipation & obviousness cited against 14 claims on app message interception.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Gregg I Anderson	500+	69%	76%
Jennifer S Bisk	500+	63%	88%
Robert J Weinschenk	600+	54%	86%

Name	Ratings
Pantech Co Ltd NPE	L2C
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5D
LG Electronics	L5D
HTC America Inc	L4C
HTC Corp	L4C
ZTE Inc	L4E
ZTE USA Inc	L4E
Pantech Wireless Inc NPE	L2C
NEC Mobile Communications Ltd	L2C
NEC Casio Mobile Communications Ltd	L2C
NEC Corp	L2C

Name	Ratings
Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP	L5A
Robert W. Busby, Jr.	L1C
John D. Zele	L1D
Mayer Brown LLP	L5A
William J. Barrow	L2C
Amanda S. Bonner	L1C
Baldine B. Paul	L1D
Robert G. Pluta	L1E
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L5B
Richard W. Thill	L1B
Steven A. Moore	L1B
HC Park & Associates	L1C
Steven B. Kelber	L2D
Alan A. Wright	L1B
Nathan H. Cristler	---- --

Name	Ratings
Cellular Communications Equipment LLC NPE	L4A
Nokia Siemens Networks Oy	---- --

Name	Ratings
Martin Ferraro LLP	L4A
Amedo Ferraro	L2A
Nelson Bumgardner Albritton	L4A
Barry Bumgardner	L1A
Burns & Levinson LLP	L2D
Jerry Cohen	L1C