DCT

2:11-cv-00390

Negotiated Data Solutions Inc v. Apple Inc

General

Filed

09/07/11

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (12/11/12)

Patent Owner

NPE (W)

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
James R. Gilstrap	--	67%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Negotiated Data Solutions Inc NPE	---- --

Attorney

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Apple Inc	L5A
Nokia Inc	L5A
Nokia Corp	L5A
Samsung Telecommunications America LLP	L5C
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC	L5C
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5C
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5C
Motorola Mobility LLC	L4A
Motorola Mobility Inc	L4A
HTC Corp	L3A
HTC America Inc	L3A
Research In Motion Ltd	L3A
Research In Motion Corp	L3A

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5A
Michael J. Forbes	L5D
Peter J. Chassman	L4A
Jonathan E. Retsky	L4A
John R. Keville	L4A
Michelle C. Replogle	L3B
Kathleen B. Barry	L3C
Potter MintonLocal	L5A
Michael E. Jones	L5A
John F. Bufe	L4A
Baker Botts LLP	L5B
Michael J. Barta	L5A
Rafik P. Zeineddin	L4B
Neil P. Sirota	L4E
Eric J. Faragi	L3A
McDermott Will & Emery LLP	L5D
Philip Ou	L5E
Yar R. Chaikovsky	L4C
David M. Beckwith	L4D
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5E
Harry Lee Gillam, Jr.	L5C
Melissa R. Smith	L5E
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L4A
Michael C. Smith	L5A
Bryan H. Burg	L1B
King & Spalding LLP	L4B
Robert F. Perry	L4A
Allison H. Altersohn	L4B
Mark H. Francis	L4B
Christopher C. Carnaval	L2B
Irell & Manella LLP	L4B
Nima Hefazi	L5E
Alan J. Heinrich	L4A
Jonathan R. Lange	L3C
Beck Redden & SecrestLocal	L3A
Michael E. Richardson	L3B
Joe W. Redden, Jr.	L2A
Robert D. Daniel	L1D
O'Melveny & Myers LLP	L3C
John K. Murray	L4D
Haltom & DoanLocal	L2A
Jennifer H. Doan	L3B
Stephen W. Creekmore, IV	L1C
Milbank Tweed Hadley & McCloy LLP	L2B
Christopher J. Gaspar	L5A
Mark C. Scarsi	L5B
Miguel J. Ruiz	L4C
Jennifer L. Miremadi	L3B