DCT

2:10-cv-00574

Geotag Inc v. Western Union Co

General

Filed

12/18/10

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

SourcePACER

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
James R. Gilstrap	01/04/12 - 07/01/14	36%
Michael H. Schneider, Sr.	02/23/12 - 01/02/14	32%
David Folsom	12/20/10 - 02/23/12	40%

MagistrateCharles C. Everingham, IV, Roy S. Payne, Caroline M. Craven

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Geotag Inc NPE	L1C
Icims Inc	L2E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5A
Deborah J. Race	L5D
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L4A
Michael C. Smith	L3A
Spangler Law FirmLocal	L4E
Andrew W. Spangler	L4E
Tadlock Law FirmLocal	L2D
Charles C. Tadlock	L2B
Keith B. Smiley	L1D
Bell Nunnally & MartinLocal	L2E
Jeffrey A. Tinker	L1B
Buether Joe & Carpenter	L2E
Niky R. Bagley	L5B
Brian A. Carpenter	L5E
Eric W. Buether	L4E
Christopher M. Joe	L4E
Monica N. Tavakoli	L3E
Niknaz Bukovcan	L2B
Mark D. Perantie	L2E
Reese Marketos LLPLocal	L1C
Adam C. Sanderson	L1B
Joel W. Reese	L1-- --
Charles Van CleefLocal	L1C
Charles van Cleef	L1C
Anderson & CunninghamLocal	L1D
David K. Anderson	L1D
Dealy Zimmermann Clark Malouf & MacFarlaneLocal	L1D
Mark J. Zimmermann	L1D
Turner Dealy Zimmermann & ClarkLocal	L1D
Thomas C. Clark	---- --
Ni Law Firm PLLC	L1D
Stevenson Moore, V	L3D
Timothy T. Wang	L3D
Ni Wang Associates PLLC	L1D
Hao Ni	L3B
Preti Flaherty Beliveau Pachios	L1D
Denise C. Lane	L3C
Mount & Stoelker	L1E
Daniel S. Mount	L4D
Kevin M. Pasquinelli	L3C
William H. Stewart	L2-- --
Gardner Haas PLLCLocal	L1-- --
Eric P. Haas	---- --
Michael S. Gardner	---- --
Spickard LawLocal	L1-- --
Todd S. Spickard	L1-- --
David W Collins IP LawLocal	---- --
David R. Bennett	L2C
Malouf & Nockels LLPLocal	---- --
Jonathan A. Nockels	---- --
Jeremy C. Martin	---- --
Stephen F. Malouf	---- --
Michael Tobolowsky	---- --

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Western Union Holdings Inc	---- --
Western Union Financial Services Inc	---- --
Western Union Co	---- --
Whole Foods Market Services Inc	L5A
Whole Foods Market Inc	L5A
Dollar General Corp	L3A
Home Depot USA Inc	L3C
Home Depot	L3C
OMX Inc	L2A
Officemax	L2A
Office Depot LLC	L2A
Office Depot Inc	L2A
Quest Diagnostics Inc	L2A
Lowes Companies Inc	L2A
Lowe S Cos Inc	L2A
Ticketmaster LLC	L2A
Live Nation Worldwide Inc	L2A
Live Nation Entertainment Inc	L2A
CVS Pharmacy Inc	L2A
Pacific Biosciences Of California Inc	L2B
Walgreens Corp	L2B
Walgreen Co	L2B
Bath & Body Works LLC	L2B
Bath & Body Works Direct Inc	L2B
Family Dollar Stores Inc	L2B
Fifth Third Bank National Association	L2C
Fifth Third Bank	L2C
Fifth Third Bancorp	L2C
Laboratory Corp	L2D
MapQuest Inc	L2E
Homer TLC Inc	L2E
Scotts Co LLC	L1B
Therma-Tru Corp	L1B
Therma Tru Corp	L1B
Burt S Bees Inc	L1B
Taser Intl Inc	L1C
New Albertsons Inc	L1D
Albertsons LLC	L1D
Suntrust Banks Inc	L1D
Suntrust Bank	L1D
New Albertson S Inc	L1D
Whole Foods Market IP LP	---- --
doing Business Asticketmasters LLC	---- --
Swan Corp	---- --
Mattress Firm Inc	---- --
Mattress Giant Corp	---- --
Steelcase Inc	---- --
Southern States Cooperative	---- --
Pip Inc	---- --
Piggy Wiggly LLC	---- --
Olson + Co Inc	---- --
Medela LLC	---- --
Medela Inc	---- --
Winn Dixie Stores Inc	---- --
Learning Express Inc	---- --
Jim's Formal Wear Co	---- --
Jim S Formal Wear Co	---- --
Jelly Belly Candy Co	---- --
Heb Grocery Co LP	---- --
Famly Dollar Inc	---- --
Piggly Wiggly LLC	---- --
Burts Bees Inc	---- --
Build A Bear Workshop Inc	---- --
Brookshire Brothers Ltd	---- --
Best Maid Products Inc	---- --
Beech Nut Nutrition Corp	---- --
Albertson S Inc	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
K&L Gates	L5A
Michael J. Bettinger	L5A
Steven G. Schortgen	L5A
Jennifer K. Ayers	L4A
Irene I. Yang	L3A
Christy V. La Pierre	L3C
Potter MintonLocal	L5A
Allen F. Gardner	L5A
Michael E. Jones	L5A
John F. Bufe	L4A
Daniel A. Noteware, Jr.	L1B
Wildman Harrold Allen & Dixon LLP	L5A
Edward T. Walker	L4A
John S. Letchinger	L4E
Douglas S. Rupert	L3C
Winston Taylor LLP	L5A
Thomas M. Melsheimer	L5A
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5A
Matias Ferrario	L3A
Leslie T. Grab	---- --
Gardere Wynne Sewell LLP	L5A
William D. Dunn	---- --
Hunton & Williams LLP	L5A
Brian Buroker	L4A
Michael A. Oakes	L4A
Christopher M. First	L4E
Ozzie Farres	L2B
Edward F. Fernandes	---- --
Fran R. Aden	---- --
Fulbright & Jaworski LLP	L5A
Michael C. Barrett	L5E
Charles S. Baker	L4C
Mark T. Garrett	L3A
Sarah R. Holland	L3E
Michael A. Swartzendruber	---- --
Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP	L5A
Brandon J. Karam	L2B
DLA Piper US LLP	L5B
Nicholas G. Papastavros	L5D
Jeffrey L. Johnson	L4B
Robert W. Kantner	L4B
Ryan W. Cobb	L4C
Andrew P. Valentine	L4C
John M. Guaragna	L4D
Brian K. Erickson	L4E
Henning Schmidt	L3A
Amy P. Mohan	L3A
Erik Fuehrer	L3B
Jesse Hindman	L3D
Fish & Richardson	L5B
Bailey K. Benedict	L5A
Neil J. McNabnay	L5A
James E. Youngblood	L5B
David J. Healey	L5C
Taj J. Clayton	L3B
Jane J. Du	L3C
Michael A. Bittner	L3C
Wasif H. Qureshi	L3C
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5B
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5B
Daymon J. Rambin	L4E
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5B
Melissa R. Smith	L5B
Andrew T. Gorham	L5C
Bobby Lamb	L1C
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5E
Charles Ainsworth	L5D
Alston & Bird LLP	L4A
Alan Lee Whitehurst	L4A
Robert L. Lee	L4D
Frank G. Smith, III	L4E
Jason W. Cook	L4E
Kamran Jivani	L3B
Adam Swain	L2C
Derek S. Neilson	L2C
Brinks Hofer Gilson & Lione	L4A
William H. Frankel	L5C
Laura A. Lydigsen	L4E
Cozen Oconnor	L4A
Martin B. Pavane	L5A
Lisa A. Ferrari	L4C
Heartfield Law FirmLocal	L4A
J. Thad Heartfield	L5A
M. Dru Montgomery	L5B
Cohen Pontani Lieberman & Pavane	L4A
Mher Hartoonian	L4B
Craig C. Crafton	---- --
Cozen O'Connor	L4A
Kendall R. Kelly	---- --
Christopher J. Hanlon	---- --
Baker Botts LLP	L4B
Scott F. Partridge	L5E
William Rothwell	L3C
Elizabeth D. Flannery	L3E
Jennifer P. Adams	L1C
Findlay CraftLocal	L4B
Eric H. Findlay	L5A
Roger B. Craft	L5E
Michael D. Findlay	L1C
Yarbrough Wilcox PLLCLocal	L4B
Herbert A. Yarbrough, III	L5D
Debra E. Gunter	L3A
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L4E
Nixon Peabody LLP	L3B
Jodi R. Wine	L5B
Russell J. Genet	L5E
Jason C. Kravitz	L4D
Ramey & FlockLocal	L3B
Shannon M. Dacus	L5A
Deron R. Dacus	L4A
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3B
Clayton C. James	L4C
Srecko Vidmar	L4D
Williams Morgan & AmersonLocal	L3B
Danny L. Williams	L5A
Christopher N. Cravey	L4A
Michael A. Benefield	L4A
Brian K. Buss	L2B
Terry D. Morgan	L2D
David K. Wooten	L1D
Haynes & Boone LLP	L3B
Phillip B. Philbin	L5A
Charles M. Jones, II	L4E
Dykema Gossett LLP	L3B
David G. Henry	L5C
Allan J. Sternstein	L5C
Timothy K. Sendek	L4C
Baker & McKenzie LLP	L3D
Mark D. Taylor	L4C
Nathan A. Engels	L4E
Brian C. McCormack	L4E
Andrew C. Moreton	---- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L3E
Robin L. McGrath	L4E
Edward J. Benz, III	L4E
Kane Russell Coleman & LoganLocal	L2B
Zach T. Mayer	---- --
McGinnis Lochridge LLPLocal	L2B
Travis C. Barton	L1D
Coghlan Crowson LLPLocal	L2B
Stayton L. Worthington	L1D
Seyforth Shaw	L2C
Matthew A. Werber	L3B
Seyfarth Shaw LLP	L2C
Daniel J. Schwartz	L4D
Kelley Drye & Warren LLP	L2E
Robert G. Graham	L3B
Fredrikson & Byron PA	L2E
Lora M. Friedemann	L5B
Ted C. Koshiol	L3D
Mercy Carter Tidwell LLPLocal	L2E
John R. Mercy	L1-- --
Evans DixonLocal	L1C
Don V. Kelly	L1C
Benjamin M. Fletcher	L1D
Eugene P. Schmittgens, Jr.	---- --
Christensen O'Connor Johnson Kindness PLLC	L1C
Michael N. Zachary	L4A
John D. Denkenberger	L4E
Greensfelder Hemker & Gale	L1D
Mary Ann L. Wymore	---- --
J. Andrew Walkup	---- --
Gruber Hurst Johansen & Hail LLPLocal	L1D
Anthony J. Magee	L1D
Michael K. Hurst	L1D
Lewis Rice	L1D
Michael J. Hickey	L4E
Ward Zinna	L1E
John F. Ward	L5E
Michael J. Zinna	L4C
Matthew C. Berntsen	L3C
Patrick R. Colsher	L3D
Boutin Jones IncLocal	---- --
Chris Gibson	---- --
Maralee Eriksen	---- --
Glast Phillips & MurrayLocal	---- --
Richard E. Young	---- --
Martin Disiere Jefferson & WisdomLocal	---- --
Douglas H. Elliott	L1D
Dale Jefferson	L1D
Fletcher Farley Shipman & Salinas LLPLocal	---- --
Douglas D. Fletcher	---- --
Keith A. Robb	---- --
Chamberlain Hrdlicka White Williams & MartinLocal	---- --
Randall K. Hawes	---- --
Attorney at LawLocal	---- --
Antoinette M. Tease	---- --
Clayton E. Dark, Jr.	---- --