DCT

2:09-cv-00274

PalTalk Holdings Inc v. Sony Computer Entertainment America Inc

General

Filed

09/14/09

Cause of ActionWillful Patent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (10/25/11)

Patent Owner

Operating Company (L)

SourcePACER

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
David Folsom	09/17/09 - 10/25/11	43%
T. John Ward	09/17/09 - 09/17/09	53%

MagistrateCharles C. Everingham, IV, Caroline M. Craven

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
PalTalk Holdings Inc	L1D

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5A
Deborah J. Race	L5D
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5D
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5D
S. Calvin Capshaw	L5E
Daymon J. Rambin	L5E
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5E
Jack W. Hill	L5A
Thomas J. Ward, Jr.	L5A
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5E
Robert C. Bunt	L5E
Charles Ainsworth	L5E
Dorsey & Whitney LLP	L4A
Douglas R. Wilson	L5C
Michael F. Heim	L4B
Niraj P. Patel	---- --
Susman Godfrey LLP	L3D
Max L. Tribble	L4E
Brooke A. M. Taylor	L3B
Matthew Behncke	L3E
Kalpana Srinivasan	L1B
Amira Mae El-Hakam	---- --
David M. Peterson	---- --
Heim Payne & Chorush LLP	L1D
Nathan J. Davis	L4C
Micah J. Howe	L3D
Cooper Byron EsquireLocal	---- --
Byron W. Cooper	---- --

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Sony Computer Entertainment America Inc	L5A
Sony Online Entertainment LLC	L5A
Sony Corp	L5A
Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC	L5A
Blizzard Entertainment Inc	L5A
Activision Publishing Inc	L5A
Activision Blizzard Inc	L5A
Turbine Inc	L3A
Jagex Ltd	L3A
Ncsoft Corp	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5A
Vincent J. Belusko	L4A
Jason J. Lee	L4B
Brian F. McMahon	L4C
Scott C. Moore	L4C
Potter MintonLocal	L5A
John F. Bufe	L5C
Michael E. Jones	L5D
Allen F. Gardner	L5E
McKool Smith	L5A
Jennifer L. Truelove	L5E
Samuel F. Baxter	L4A
Jason D. Cassady	L3B
Ropes & Gray LLP	L4A
David S. Chun	L5A
Matthew R. Clements	L4A
Gene W. Lee	L4B
Tal Kedem	L4B
Jesse J. Jenner	L4E
Brian P. Biddinger	L3C
Hanyong Lee	---- --
Irell & Manella LLP	L4B
Eric B. Hanson	L5A
Blake B. Greene	L5B
Morgan Chu	L4A
Elliot Brown	L4D
Peter E. Gratzinger	L3B
Andrew P. Nguyen	L3B
Ellisen S. Turner	L3E
Jorge L. Fernandez	---- --
Latham & Watkins LLP	L4B
Ron E. Shulman	L4E
Robert Steinberg	L3A
Franklin D. Kang	L3E
Renny F. Hwang	L3E
Charles P. Courtenay	L1-- --
Jeff Myung	---- --
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L4C
Lawrence A. Phillips	L5E
Clyde M. Siebman	L5E
Yarbrough Wilcox PLLCLocal	L4E
Melvin R. Wilcox, III	L5D
Cooley LLP	L4E
Christopher C. Campbell	L4A
Thomas J. Friel, Jr.	L4A
Richard S. Sanders	L4E
Heather A. Faltin	L3C
Banner & Witcoff LTD	L3A
V. Bryan Medlock, Jr.	L5B
Audra C. Eidem Heinze	L4A
Timothy C. Meece	L4A
Christopher B. Roth	L4D
Ross A. Dannenberg	---- --
Young Pickett & LeeLocal	L2A
John M. Pickett	L5C
Damon M. Young	L4D
WYLY Rommel PLLCLocal	L1C
Sean F. Rommel	L1B