DCT

2:07-cv-00555

Beneficial Innovations Inc v. AOL LLC

General

Filed

12/20/07

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorMech Eng, Manuf

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
T. John Ward	--	53%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Beneficial Innovations Inc NPE	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5A
Jessica Lea Hannah	L5A
Jones Day	L5A
Franklin Jones, Jr.	L4A
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5E
Claire A. Henry	L3E
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5E
Robert C. Bunt	L5D
Charles Ainsworth	L5E
Brown McCarroll	L4B
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L4B
S. Calvin Capshaw	L4C
Dovel & Luner	L2E
Julien A. Adams	L5E
Gregory S. Dovel	L4E
Fairchild Price Haley Smith LLPLocal	---- --
Daymon J. Rambin	L3E

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
AOL LLC	L5A
Yahoo Inc	L5A
YouTube LLC	L4A
Google LLC	L4A
Tribune Media Co	L1B
Morris Communications Co LLC	---- --
Dallas Morning News Inc	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP	L5A
Tigran Vardanian	L5A
Michael C. Smith	L5D
Charles K. Verhoeven	L4A
Jennifer A. Kash	L3A
Kevin A. Smith	L3D
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5A
Cosmin Maier	L5A
Christine E. Duh	L5A
Mark G. Matuschak	L5B
Victor F. Souto	L4A
Irah H. Donner	L4C
Katie M. Saxton	L3A
Vinita Ferrera	L3A
Violetta G. Watson	L2C
Potter MintonLocal	L5D
Michael E. Jones	L5E
Diane Devasto	L3A
John F. Bufe	L3B
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L4E
Melissa R. Smith	L4E
Banner & Witcoff LTD	L3A
V. Bryan Medlock, Jr.	L5E
United States Securities & Exchange Commission	L3B
David A. Foley	---- --
Latham & Watkins LLP	L3B
Kevin C. May	L5D
David S. Foster	L4D
Mayer Brown LLP	L3E
Steven Yovits	L4A
Conley Rose	L1C
Jonathan M. Pierce	L5E
Gregory L. Maag	L4E
Michael J. Guthrie	L3E
Chen Malin LLP	L1E
Steven C. Malin	L5C
Ericsson IncLocal	---- --
Kelley A. Conaty	---- --
Hull Towill Norman Barrett & Salley	---- --
Timothy E. Moses	---- --
David E. Hudson	---- --