DCT

2:06-cv-00072

DataTreasury Corp v. Wells Fargo & Co

General

Filed

02/24/06

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (08/03/11)

Patent Owner

NPE (W)

PACER2:06-cv-00072

Appeals07-1317

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
David Folsom	04/12/06 - 10/17/17	43%

MagistrateAmos L. Mazzant, III, Charles C. Everingham, IV, John D. Love, Caroline M. Craven, Earl S. Hines

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
DataTreasury Corp NPE	L2E
Viewpointe Archive Services LLC	---- --
Tgip Inc	---- --
Data Treasury Corp NPE	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5D
Thomas J. Ward, Jr.	L5A
Johnny Ward, Jr.	L1B
Albritton Law FirmLocal	L4C
Eric M. Albritton	L5A
Adam A. Biggs	L3A
Nix Patterson & Roach LLPLocal	L1B
Anthony K. Bruster	L1A
Rodney A. Cooper	L1A
Nicole R. Kliewer	L1B
Edward K. Chin	L1C
Richard B. King	L1C
Andrew J. Wright	L1D
Karl A. Rupp	L1E
Nelson J. Roach	L1E
Edward L. Hohn	---- --
Nida Nadir	---- --
Harold W. Nix	---- --
Brady Paddock	---- --
Nix Patterson Roach LLPLocal	L1B
David N. Smith	L1B
Derek Tod Gilliland	L1E
Charles C. Patterson	---- --
Kendall Law Group LLPLocal	L1B
Joe Kendall	L1D
Caldwell Cassady Curry	L1C
Bradley W. Caldwell	L3B
Dreier LLP	L1D
Marc S. Dreier	---- --
Gilbert's LLPLocal	---- --
Sara C. Zborovski	---- --
Shonagh McVean	---- --
Alexander J. Stack	---- --
Elizabeth S. Depchand	---- --
Timothy H. Gilbert	---- --

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Wells Fargo & Co	L2A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L5A
Verizon Communications Inc	L5A
MCI Communications Services Inc	L5A
Bell Atlantic Communications Inc	L5A
Citizens Financial Group Inc	L3A
PNC Financial Services Group Inc	L3B
PNC Bank National Association	L3B
National City Corp	L3B
National City Bank	L3B
Zions First National Bank	L3C
Zions Bancorp	L3C
US Bank National Association	L3C
US Bancorp Corp	L3C
Harris NA	L3E
Harris Bankcorp Inc	L3E
Wells Fargo Bank National Association	L2A
Wachovia Corp	L2A
Wachovia Bank NA	L2A
Frost National Bank	L2B
Cullen Frost Bankers Inc	L2B
Comerica Inc	L2B
Comerica Bank & Trust NA	L2B
Comerica Bank	L2B
Bancorpsouth Inc	L2B
Bancorpsouth Bank	L2B
Suntrust Banks Inc	L2C
Suntrust Bank	L2C
Branch Banking Trust Co	L2C
BB&T Corp	L2C
HSBC North America Holdings Inc	L2C
HSBC Bank USA NA	L2C
Remitco LLC	L2D
Bank Of New York Mellon Corp	L2D
Bank Of New York Co Inc	L2D
Bank Of New York	L2D
Telecheck Services Inc	L1A
First Data Corp	L1A
Toronto-Dominion Bank	L1B
RBS Citizens NA	L1B
First Tennessee Bank National Association	L1B
First Tennessee Bank NA	L1B
First Horizon National Corp	L1B
Keycorp	L1B
Keybank National Association	L1B
Compass Bank	L1B
Compass Bancshares Inc	L1B
Electronic Data Systems Corp	L1C
Lasalle Bank National Association	L1C
Lasalle Bank NA	L1C
Lasalle Bank Corp	L1C
Bank of America National Association	L1C
Bank of America Corp	L1C
First-Citizens Bank Trust Co	L1C
First-Citizens Bank & Trust Co	L1C
First Citizens Bancshares Inc	L1C
M&T Bank Corp	L1D
M&T Bank	L1D
M & T Bank	L1D
All Defendants	L1D
UBS Americas Inc	---- --
Symcor Inc	---- --
Royal Bank of Canada	---- --
National Bank of Canada	---- --
MT Bank	---- --
Unionbancal Corp	---- --
Union Bank of California National Association	---- --
Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi Ufj Ltd	---- --
Magtek Inc	---- --
Layn R Phillips	---- --
Hon Layn R Phillips	---- --
Deutsche Bank Trust Co	---- --
Small Value Payments Co LLC	---- --
Clearing House Payments Co LLC	---- --
City National Bank	---- --
Intria Items Inc	---- --
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce	---- --
Bank Of Montreal	---- --
BBT Corp	---- --
Bank of Novia Scotia	---- --
Bank of Nova Scotia	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5A
John J. Feldhaus	L5B
John T. Gutkoski	L5B
Jason J. Keener	L5B
Lisa S. Mankofsky	L5C
Liane M. Peterson	L5C
George C. Beck	L4A
C. Edward Polk, Jr.	L4C
Anthony H. Son	L4D
Ryan S. Bewersdorf	L3B
Kimberly K. Dodd	L3D
Michael C. Lueder	---- --
Sidley Austin LLP	L5A
Jeffrey A. Finn	L5B
Tung Nguyen	L5B
V. Bryan Medlock, Jr.	L5E
James P. Bradley	L4A
Edward G. Poplawski	L4E
Catherine I. Rajwani	L3B
Jennifer L. Jadlow	L3E
Carissa A. Tener	---- --
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5A
Alton Absher, III	L5A
Audra A. Dial	L5A
Danielle Williams	L5A
Michael J. Turton	L5B
Bret T. Winterle	L5E
Stephen E. Baskin	L4A
Amr O. Aly	L4B
William H. Boice	L4B
Steven Gardner	L4B
Eric L. Sophir	L4C
Wilson L. White	L3A
Jon R. Pierce	L3C
Leroy M. Toliver	L3C
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5A
John M. Hintz	L5A
Wayne L. Stoner	L5E
Irah H. Donner	L4C
Christie Parker & Hale LLP	L5A
Joel A. Kauth	L5E
David A. Dillard	L4C
Potter MintonLocal	L5B
Michael E. Jones	L5E
E. Glenn Thames, Jr.	L3C
Andrews Kurth Kenyon LLP	L5B
Gerald C. Conley	L5A
John H. McDowell, Jr.	L3A
Tonya M. Gray	L3E
McKool Smith	L5B
William Davis	L5B
David Sochia	L5D
Geoffrey L. Smith	L5D
Scott W. Hejny	L4A
Garret W. Chambers	L4A
Samuel F. Baxter	L4A
Ivan Wang	L4B
Theodore Stevenson, III	L4C
Peter J. Ayers	L4D
Kevin Kneupper	L4D
Martin C. Robson	L3A
Jill F. Lynch	L3B
Luke F. McLeroy	L3B
Robert M. Manley	L3D
Victoria Wicken	L3E
Jennifer L. Henry	L3-- --
Laurie L. Fitzgerald	L2A
Douglas C. Edwards	L1D
Lesley D. Anderson	---- --
DLA Piper US LLP	L5B
Jeffrey L. Johnson	L4D
Amy P. Mohan	L3B
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5C
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5D
S. Calvin Capshaw	L5E
Fish & Richardson	L5C
Timothy Devlin	L5B
P. Weston Musselman, Jr.	L5B
Michael W. Johnson	L5C
Michael A. Bittner	L5C
Juanita R. Brooks	L4A
Thomas M. Melsheimer	L4A
Taj J. Clayton	L4B
Robert C. Earle	L4C
Michael M. Rosen	L3A
Lewis E. Hudnell, III	L3C
John M. Helms	---- --
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5E
Robert M. Parker	L5A
Robert C. Bunt	L5E
Charles Ainsworth	L5E
Andrew T. Gorham	L3B
Heartfield Law FirmLocal	L4A
J. Thad Heartfield	L5A
Spangler Law LongviewLocal	L4A
Andrew W. Spangler	L5A
Fitzpatrick Cella Harper & Scinto	L4B
Stephen E. Belisle	L5A
Ronald A. Clayton	---- --
Alston & Bird LLP	L4B
Rachel M. Capoccia	L5A
Ross R. Barton	L3A
Baker Botts LLP	L4E
Steven G. Schortgen	L5A
Larry D. Carlson	L4D
Timothy S. Durst	L3E
Kevin E. Cadwell	L2A
Jeffrey A. Lamken	L1D
Fernando Rodriguez, Jr.	L1-- --
Chad Pinson	---- --
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L4E
Harry Lee Gillam, Jr.	L4E
Roth Law FirmLocal	L3A
Carl R. Roth	L3B
Amanda A. Abraham	L2A
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L3A
Glen M. Boudreaux	L1-- --
Tim S. Leonard	---- --
Edward J. Nicholas	---- --
Carl R RothLocal	L3A
Michael C. Smith	L5A
Brendan C. Roth	L2A
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L3A
Robert M. Fuhrer	L5B
Scott J. Pivnick	L5B
William P. Atkins	L4A
Raymond L. Sweigart	L4B
Guillermo E. Baeza	---- --
Vinson & Elkins LLP	L3B
William L. Lafuze	L5B
Scott W. Breedlove	L4B
Andrew E. Jackson	---- --
D. Ferguson McNiel	---- --
Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP	L3B
Marti A. Johnson	L4C
P. Anthony Sammi	L3C
Paramjeet S. Sammi	L3C
James Y. Pak	L3C
Joseph R. Sozzani	---- --
Irell & Manella LLP	L3C
Morgan Chu	L5B
David I. Gindler	L5C
Layn R. Phillips	L4C
Elizabeth L. Rosenblatt	---- --
Mayer Brown LLP	L3C
Jeremy P. Welch	---- --
Baker & McKenzie LLP	L3D
Jay F. Utley	L5A
Kevin M. O'Brien	L5B
Howard N. Wisnia	L5B
W. Barton Rankin	L5C
James P. Conley	L4B
John G. Flaim	L4C
Charles Dick	---- --
Brian J. Hurst	---- --
Germer Gertz LLPLocal	L3D
Lawrence L. Germer	L3E
Charles W. Goehringer, Jr.	L3E
Karen R. Bennett	---- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L3E
Brandon M. White	L5B
Paul J. Wilson	L4B
Robert M. Masters	L4E
Christopher W. Kennerly	L3B
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L3E
Melvin R. Wilcox, III	L4E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L4E
Haynes & Boone LLP	L2B
Phillip B. Philbin	L4A
John R. Emerson	L4A
Claude E WelchLocal	L2C
Claude E. Welch	L2C
Beck Redden & SecrestLocal	L2D
David J. Beck	L3E
Michael E. Richardson	L2E
Joe W. Redden, Jr.	L1A
Robert D. Daniel	L1B
Timothy A. Cleveland	---- --
Russ August & Kabat	L1B
Andrew D. Weiss	L5E
Flowers Davis LLPLocal	L1B
Preston W. McGee	L1-- --
Smith Weber LLPLocal	L1B
Robert W. Weber	L1A
Daffer McDaniel LLPLocal	L1C
Stacy L. Zoern	L1C
Kurt M. Sauer	---- --
Sullivan & Cromwell LLP	L1D
James T. Williams	L4C
Jane J. Jaang	L3B
Bruce E. Clark	---- --
James H. Carter	---- --
Charhon Callahan Robson Garza PLLC	L1D
Steven C. Callahan	L5C
Christopher T. Bovenkamp	L5E
Standley Law Group LLP	L1E
James L. Kwak	L4E
Jeffrey S. Standley	L4E
F. Michael Speed, Jr.	L4E
Belair & Perrone LLPLocal	---- --
Gregory Perrone	---- --
Law Offices Of Richard GraingerLocal	---- --
George R. Grainger	---- --
Jeremy Michael Thompson EsqLocal	---- --
Jeremy M. Thompson	---- --
Lance LeeLocal	---- --
Lance Lee	---- --
Attorney at LawLocal	---- --
Guy N. Harrison	---- --