DCT

1:12-cv-01533

Pragmatus Telecom LLC v. Newegg Inc

General

Filed

11/21/12

Cause of ActionInfringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (02/18/16)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

PACER1:12-cv-01533

Appeals14-1777

CourtD. Delaware

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Richard G. Andrews	--	27%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Pragmatus Telecom LLC NPE	L2E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Farnan LLPLocal	L3E
Brian Farnan	L4E
Sal Lim	L1C
David Alberti	L1C
Feinberg Day Alberti & Thompson LLP	L2C
Ian N. Feinberg	L5A
Margaret E. Day	L5A
Clayton Thompson	L5B
Marc Belloli	L4A
Yakov Zolotorev	L3B
Vinay K. Malik	L2C

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Newegg Inc	L3A
Lenovo United States Inc	L5A
Sprint Spectrum LP	L5A
EMC Corp	L5A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L5A
AT&T Inc	L5A
Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc	L5A
3M Innovative Properties Co	L5A
3M Co Inc	L5A
Perkin-Elmer Inc	L4A
General Motors LLC	L4A
Oriental Trading Co Inc	L4B
Staples Inc	L3A
Office Depot Inc	L3A
Bosch Security Systems LLC	L3A
Bosch Security Systems Inc	L3A
Neweggcom Inc	L3A
HSN LP	L3A
HSN Inc	L3A
CDW LLC	L3A
Volkswagen Group of America Inc	L3B
Thomson Reuters Corp	L3B
Rite-Aid Corp	L3B
First Data Corp	L2A
Frontier Communications Corp NPE	L2B
Crocs Inc	L2B
Elavon Inc	L2B
Goemerchant LLC	L2B
Brother Intl Corp	L2C
Starwood Hotels Resorts Worldwide Inc	L2E
Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide Inc	L2E
Seagate Technology US Holdings Inc	L2E
Seagate Technology LLC	L2E
Seagate Technology Holdings Inc	L2E
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories Inc	L1B
Reed Elsevier US Holdings Inc	L1C
Syntellect Inc	L1C
Enghouse Interactive Inc	L1C
Apropos Technology Inc	L1C
Sakscom LLC	L1D
U-Haul Intl Inc	L1D
U Haul Intl Inc	L1D
eGain Corp	---- --
Aramark Corp	---- --
Aramark	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell LLPLocal	L5A
Jack B. Blumenfeld	L5A
Karen Jacobs	L4A
Rodger D. Smith, II	L4A
Michael J. Flynn	L3A
Mary B. Graham	L3B
Paul Saindon	L2A
Locke Lord LLP	L5A
John F. Sweeney	L5C
Steven F. Meyer	L4B
Sergey Kolmykov	L3C
Joseph A. Farco	L2C
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5A
Steven A. Moore	L5A
William H. Boice	L5A
John C. Alemanni	L4B
Michael Morlock	L3B
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati	L5A
Larry L. Shatzer	L5A
Vera M. Elson	L5B
Paul M. McAdams	L2D
Kate P. Mahaffy	---- --
Anthony J. Weibell	---- --
Potter Anderson & Corroon LLPLocal	L5A
Richard L. Horwitz	L5A
David E. Moore	L5A
Philip A. Rovner	L3C
Bindu Ann George Palapura	L3C
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5A
Karen L. Hagberg	L4B
Craig B. Whitney	---- --
Fish & Richardson	L5B
Neil J. McNabnay	L5A
P. Weston Musselman, Jr.	L5B
William C. Shear	L4B
Susan E. Morrison	L3C
DLA Piper US LLP	L5B
John M. Guaragna	L5C
Courtney T. Stewart	L4A
James M. Heintz	L4B
Denise S. Kraft	L4D
Aleine M. Porterfield	L3B
Brian A. Biggs	L2B
McDermott Will & Emery LLP	L5C
Hasan M. Rashid	L3C
Alston & Bird LLP	L4A
Shaun W. Hassett	L5C
Jason W. Cook	L5E
Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP	L4A
Patrick J. Kelleher	L5D
Carrie A. Beyer	L4E
Todd C. Schiltz	---- --
Faegre Baker Daniels LLP	L4A
Natalie Hanlon-Leh	L5A
Jared B. Briant	L4B
Ashby & GeddesLocal	L4B
John G. Day	L4A
Andrew C. Mayo	L4A
Lauren E. Maguire	L4C
Steven J. Balick	L4D
Duane Morris LLP	L4D
Benjamin A. Smyth	L5A
John R. Gibson	L4A
L. Norwood Jameson	L4B
Gary W. Lipkin	L4D
Paul Hastings LLP	L4E
Elizabeth L. Brann	L5A
Thomas A. Counts	L4D
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP	L3A
Eric J. Klein	L5A
Fred I. Williams	L4A
John Wittenzellner	L3B
Marshall Gerstein & Borun LLP	L3A
Tron Yue Fu	L2C
GibbonsLocal	L3B
David E. Delorenzi	L3A
Christopher H. Strate	L1C
Christopher Viceconte	L1C
Proskauer Rose LLP	L3C
Steven M. Bauer	L5B
Kimberly A. Mottley	L5B
Joel Cavanaugh	L3C
Wiley Rein LLP	L3C
Anthony H. Son	L5E
Ryan M. Corbett	---- --
Polsinelli	L3E
Russell S. Jones, Jr.	L5A
Richard P. Stitt	L5B
Joshua McCaig	L4B
Shanti M. Katona	L3D
Christopher M. Coggins	L2C
Seyfarth Shaw LLP	L2C
Joseph R. Lanser	L5A
Vamsi Kakarla	L2-- --
Webb Law Firm	L2C
Kent E. Baldauf, Jr.	L5B
Daniel H. Brean	L4B
Choate Hall & Stewart LLP	L2C
Carlos Perez-Albuerne	L4C
G. Mark Edgarton	L4D
Carlos Perez	---- --
Anita Spieth	---- --
Ross Aronstam & Moritz LLPLocal	L2C
Benjamin J. Schladweiler	L2C
Seitz Ross Aronstam & Moritz LLPLocal	L2C
Collins J. Seitz, Jr.	L2C
Desmarais LLP	L2D
Jon T. Hohenthaner	L4B
Lowe Graham Jones PLLC	L2D
Lawrence D. Graham	L5B
Proctor Heyman LLPLocal	L2E
Dominick T. Gattuso	L2E
Ward Zinna	L1D
Michael J. Zinna	L4A
Patrick R. Colsher	L4C
Abrams & Bayliss LLPLocal	L1D
John M. Seaman	L1C
Attorney at LawLocal	---- --
Brian A. Hawkins	---- --