DCT

1:08-cv-00139

Flashpoint Technology Inc v. Aiptek Inc

General

Filed

03/07/08

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (09/01/15)

Patent Owner

NPE (W)

PACER1:08-cv-00139

CourtD. Delaware

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Gregory M. Sleet	--	46%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Flashpoint Technology Inc NPE	L1C

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Pepper Hamilton LLP	L5A
Tuhin Ganguly	L5B
William D. Belanger	L5B
Edmond D. Johnson	L5E
Gregory Len	L5E
Alexandra C. Fennell	L4A
Frank Liu	L4C
Goutam Patnaik	L4C
James G. McMillan, III	L4D
Gwendolyn Tawresey	L4D
Michael D. Stone	L3D
Andrew H. Devoogd	---- --
Ballard Spahr LLP	L3B
David J. Margules	---- --
Kelley Drye & Warren LLP	L2E
David M. Hill	L5E
Ward & Olivo	L1E
John F. Ward	L5D
John W. Olivo, Jr.	L5E
Michael J. Zinna	L4A
San Diego IP Law Group LLP	L1E
Cody R. Lejeune	L3D
Williford FirmLocal	---- --
Evan O. Williford	---- --
Ray Angelini IncLocal	---- --
James J. Merkins, Jr.	---- --
Attorney at LawLocal	---- --
James R. Hail	---- --
Michael J. Dowd	---- --
Rajesh Ray Mandlekar	---- --
Nathan R. Lindell	---- --
John J. Rice	---- --

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
DXG Technology USA Inc	---- --
Aiptek Inc	---- --
Wal-Mart Stores Inc	L5A
Cellco Partnership	L5A
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5A
LG Electronics Mobilecomm USA Inc	L5A
LG Electronics	L5A
T-Mobile USA Inc	L5A
Sprint Spectrum LP	L5A
Cingular Wireless LLC	L5A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L5A
Nokia Inc	L5A
HTC Corp	L4A
HTC America Inc	L4A
Target Corp	L4A
Motorola Wuhan Mobility Technologies Communication Co Ltd	L4A
Research In Motion Ltd	L4A
Research In Motion Corp	L4A
General Electric Co	L4E
Walgreen Co	L3A
Kyocera Wireless Corp	L3A
Kyocera Communications Inc	L3A
Pantech Wireless Inc NPE	L3A
Pantech Corp NPE	L3A
Pantech Co Ltd NPE	L3A
Pantech & Curitel Communications Inc NPE	L3A
Palm Inc	L3A
Bushnell Inc	L1B
Argus Camera Co LLC	L1B
Polaroid Corp	L1C
General Imaging Co	L1C
Leica Camera Inc	L1D
Leica Camera AG	L1D
Sakar Intl Inc	L1D
Ritz Interactive Inc	L1D
Ritz Camera Centers Inc	L1D
Vupoint Solutions Inc	---- --
Vistaquest Corp	---- --
Tabata USA Inc	---- --
Sea & Sea	---- --
Mustek Inc	---- --
Minox USA Inc	---- --
Minox GmbH	---- --
Intl Norcent Tech	---- --
Oregon Scientific Inc	---- --
DXG Technology Corp	---- --
Digital Concepts	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Kirkland & Ellis LLP	L5A
Russell E. Levine	L5E
Nyika O. Strickland	L4D
Paul D. Collier	L4D
Joel R. Merkin	L3E
Perkins Coie LLP	L5A
Ramsey M. Al-Salam	L5A
Matthew C. Bernstein	L5C
Kevin Patariu	L4A
John P. Schnurer	L4B
Kaustuv M. Das	L4B
Philip A. Morin	L3A
Di Zhang	L3C
Cheng C. Ko	L3D
Brian Wacter	---- --
Bancroft PLLC	L5A
Christopher J. Coulson	L3E
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5A
Mark A. Woodmansee	L5A
David C. Doyle	L5A
Gregory W. Reilly	L3A
Potter Anderson & Corroon LLPLocal	L5A
David E. Moore	L5A
Richard L. Horwitz	L5A
Philip A. Rovner	L3C
Doungamon Fon Muttamara-Walker	L2B
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5A
Marc N. Henschke	L4D
Michelle A. Flores	L3A
Baker Botts LLP	L5B
Jay B. Johnson	L5A
Steven G. Schortgen	L5A
David G. Wille	L5B
Robert J. Benson	L5B
Peter J. Chassman	L4A
Samir Bhavsar	L4A
Richards Layton & Finger PALocal	L5B
Frederick L. Cottrell, III	L5B
Anne S. Gaza	L4E
Steven J. Fineman	L3B
Jeffrey L. Moyer	L3E
Sarah R. Stafford	L2B
Elizabeth Rui He	L2B
Travis S. Hunter	L2D
Knobbe Martens Olson & Bear LLP	L5B
Irfan A. Lateef	L5A
Joseph R. Re	L5E
Marko Zoretic	L4C
Sidley Austin LLP	L5C
James P. Bradley	L5A
Peter H. Kang	L5B
Li Chen	L5C
Christopher P. Broderick	L4A
Tung Nguyen	L4A
Theodore W. Chandler	L4B
Daniel J. Galligan	L3C
Connolly Bove Lodge & Hutz	L4A
Arthur G. Connolly, III	L5A
Collins J. Seitz, Jr.	L5B
Kevin F. Brady	L4D
Novak Druce Quigg LLP	L4A
Paul E. Crawford	L5D
Crowell & Moring LLP	L4A
Mark M. Supko	L5A
Jeffrey D. Sanok	L5B
Brian M. Koide	L4C
Michael Bednarek	L4C
Ann M. Mace	---- --
Covington & Burling LLP	L4A
Michael M. Markman	L5A
Michael K. Plimack	L4C
David A. Garr	L3B
King & Spalding LLP	L4B
Robert F. Perry	L5A
Allison H. Altersohn	L5B
Alexas D. Skucas	L4A
Daniel C. Miller	L3B
Ashby & GeddesLocal	L4B
John G. Day	L4A
Tiffany G. Lydon	L4B
Steven J. Balick	L4E
Faegre Baker Daniels LLP	L4B
Kenneth A. Liebman	L5D
James R. Steffen	L4D
Matthew Stump	L3D
Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP	L4B
Francis Digiovanni	L5A
Duane Morris LLP	L4C
Daniel V. Folt	L4A
Matt Neiderman	L4A
Gary W. Lipkin	L4B
Shaw Keller LLPLocal	L3B
John W. Shaw	L4B
Karen E. Keller	L4E
Brian L. Ferrall	L1C
Robert A. Van Nest	L1D
Michael H. Jacobs	---- --
Ryan J. McBrayer	---- --
Eric M. Acker	---- --
Vinson & Elkins LLP	L3B
Christopher Kao	L4A
David J. Tsai	L4A
Keker Van Nest & Peters LLP	L3B
Eugene M. Paige	L4C
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L3B
William P. Atkins	L5B
Christopher K. Dorsey	L4B
Samuel E. Stubbs	L4B
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3B
Richard De Bodo	L5B
David H. Ben-Meir	L4A
Huan-Yi Lin	L3E
J. Drew Diamond	L2A
Wiley Rein LLP	L3C
James H. Wallace, Jr.	L5B
Robert J. Scheffel	L5B
Kevin P. Anderson	L4A
Brian H. Pandya	L4D
Morris James LLPLocal	L3C
Mary B. Matterer	L4B
Richard K. Herrmann	L4C
Richard D. Kirk	L4E
Ratner Prestia	L3C
Rex A. Donnelly, IV	L3C
Squire Patton Boggs US LLP	L3D
Matthew Digby	---- --
Bayard PALocal	L3E
Stephen B. Brauerman	L4E
Phillips Goldman McLaughlin & Hall PALocal	L3E
Megan C. Haney	L3B
Sayles Werbner	L3E
Jiri F. Smetana	L2D
Sheldon Mak AndersonLocal	L2B
Douglas H. Morseburg	L2A
Saul Ewing LLP	L2B
Sherry H. Flax	L3E
Whitney W. Deeney	L2C
Candice T. Aaron	---- --
Theodore Naccarella	---- --
Ezra Sutton P A	L1C
Ezra Sutton	L5B
HC Park & Associates	L1C
Hae-Chan Park	L4A
Wayne M. Helge	L4A
Hovey Williams LLP	L1D
Scott R. Brown	L5C
Jennifer C. Bailey	L4E
Smith Katzenstein & Jenkins LLPLocal	L1D
Neal C. Belgam	L2E
Kelly A. Green	L1-- --
Karish & Bjorgum	L1D
A. Eric Bjorgum	L4C
Marc Karish	L4D
East West Law GroupLocal	L1D
Richard Kim	L1-- --
Wang Hartmann Gibbs & Cauley	L1E
Franklin E. Gibbs	L5D
Richard F. Cauley	L5E
John D. van Loben Sels	L4E
Jennifer L. Ishimoto	L4E
Ellen J. Wang	L3A
Ostrolenk Faber LLP	L1E
Douglas A. Miro	L5D
Lawrence S. Rosenthal	---- --
Frisenda Quinton Nicholson	L1E
Frank Frisenda	L5E
Chen Malin LLP	L1E
Jenny Chen	L3E
Klehr Harrison Harvey Branzburg & Ellers LLP	L1E
David S. Eagle	L3E
Rossman Law PLLC	L1E
Travis A. Rossman	---- --
Parkowski Guerke & Swayze PALocal	---- --
Thomas H. Kovach	L1D
John C. Andrade	---- --
Michael W. McDermott	---- --
Michael W. Arrington	---- --
Attorney at LawLocal	---- --
Joshua S. Wyde	---- --
Shane A. Nelson	---- --
Georgianna W. Braden	---- --
Joseph D. Evans	---- --
Charles A. Blazer	---- --
Greg Reilly	---- --
John T. Gutkoski	---- --
Michelle W. Skinner	---- --
Bradley W. Bloodworth	---- --