DCT

1:06-cv-00404

St Clair IP Consultants Inc v. LG Electronics Inc

General

Filed

06/26/06

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (09/04/12)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Leonard P. Stark	--	62%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
St Clair Intellectual Property Consultants Inc NPE	L2E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Richards Layton & Finger PALocal	L5A
Frederick L. Cottrell, III	L5A
Laura D. Hatcher	L2C
Chad M. Shandler	L2D
Elizabeth Rui He	L1A
Gregory E. Stuhlman	L1A
Michelle E. Whalen	L1-- --
Robins Kaplan LLP	L4E
Shira T. Shapiro	L5E
Annie Huang	L4B
Becky R. Thorson	L4C
Ronald J. Schutz	L4E
Tara D. Falsani	L4E
Melissa A. Goodman	L4E
Carrie M. Lambert	L4E
Andrea L. Gothing	L4E
Seth A. Northrop	L3C
Busola A. Akinwale	L3D
David B. Zucco	L3E
Trevor J. Foster	L3E
William J. Rocha	L3E
Lars P. Taavola	L3E
Brock J. Specht	L2D
Mathew J. Yang	L2D
Lauren J. Galgano	L2E
Rader Fishman	L2D
R. Terrance Rader	L4D
Glenn E. Forbis	L4E
Charles W. Bradley	L3E
Seitz Van Ogtrop & Green PALocal	L1E
Patricia P. McGonigle	L1E
Jared T. Green	L1-- --

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5A
LG Electronics Mobilecomm USA Inc	L5A
LG Electronics	L5A
Motorola Wuhan Mobility Technologies Communication Co Ltd	L4A
Sanyo North America Corp	L4A
Sanyo Electric Co Ltd	L4A
T-Mobile USA Inc	L4B
Deutsche Telekom AG	L4B
Kyocera Wireless Corp	L2A
Kyocera Communications Inc	L2A
Palm Inc	L2A
HTC Corp	L2A
HTC BVI Corp	L2A
HTC America Inc	L2A
Polaroid Holding Co	L2D
Polaroid Corp	L2D
Polaroid Consumer Electronics LLC	L2D
Petters Group Worldwide LLC	L2D
High Tech Computer Corp	L1B
Concord Camera Corp	---- --
Aiptek Inc	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Kirkland & Ellis LLP	L5A
Melody D. Hansen	L4B
Russell E. Levine	L4D
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell LLPLocal	L5A
Jack B. Blumenfeld	L5A
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5A
Mark A. Woodmansee	L4A
David C. Doyle	L4A
Philip A. Morin	L4B
Brian M. Kramer	L4C
Edwin D. Buxton	L3B
Gregory W. Reilly	L2B
Christian G. Andreu-Von Euw	---- --
Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLPLocal	L5A
Karen E. Keller	L4E
Megan C. Haney	L2A
Melanie K. Sharp	L2E
James L. Higgins	L1C
Bingham McCutchen LLP	L5A
Richard De Bodo	L4B
Alston & Bird LLP	L5A
Rachel M. Capoccia	L4A
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP	L4A
Robert J. Benson	L4C
Christopher P. Broderick	L3B
Ashby & GeddesLocal	L4E
John G. Day	L4E
Lauren E. Maguire	L3E
Caroline Hong	L1B
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3B
Andrew V. Devkar	L5A
David H. Ben-Meir	L4A
Raymond A. Kurz	L4E
Proskauer Rose LLP	L3C
Steven M. Bauer	L4D
Kimberly A. Mottley	L4D
Bayard PALocal	L3E
Richard D. Kirk	L3C
Ratner Prestia	L2A
Gerard M. O'Rourke	L4B
Invista Sarl	---- --
Stephen J. MacKenzie	---- --
Attorney at LawLocal	---- --
Huan-Yi Lin	---- --
Anthony C. Roth	---- --
Rebekah L. Osborn	---- --