DCT
1:03-cv-01158
Praxair Inc v. ATMI Inc
Log In
Overview
Analysis
General
Parties
Attorneys
Patents
Related Cases
Dockets
General
Filed
12/22/03
Cause of Action
Infringement
Sector
Mech Eng, Manuf
Status
Closed (11/08/05)
Patent Owner
Operating Company
(W)
Source
PACER
Appeals
07-1483
Court
D. Delaware
Judge
Period
PO Win Rate
Sue L. Robinson
01/07/04 - 02/03/10
50%
Magistrate
Mary Pat Thynge
Plaintiff
Party
Name
Ratings
Praxair Technology Inc
L3
B
Praxair Inc
L3
B
Show all (0 more)
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell LLP
Local
L5
A
Jack B. Blumenfeld
L5
A
Rodger D. Smith, II
L3
A
Ropes & Gray LLP
L3
B
Brian P. Biddinger
L5
A
Show all (-5 more)
Defendant
Party
Name
Ratings
ATMI Inc
L3
E
Advanced Technology Materials Inc
L3
E
Show all (0 more)
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Richards Layton & Finger PA
Local
L4
D
Frederick L. Cottrell, III
L3
B
Kelly E. Farnan
L3
E
Robert H. Richards, III
--
--
--
Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP
L1
B
Alyssa M. Schwartz
L3
A
Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP
L1
D
Keith A. Walter, Jr.
L5
A
Nicholas L. Coch
L5
B
Theodore J. Mlynar
L4
C
Show all (0 more)