DCT

3:09-cv-02535

SPH America LLC v. Acer Inc

General

Filed

11/09/09

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

PACER3:09-cv-02535

CourtS.D. California

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Cathy Ann Bencivengo	--	23%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
SPH America LLC NPE	L1E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP	L5B
Rajeev Gupta	L5D
Minjae Kang	L4A
E. Robert Yoches	L4B
Christopher S. Schultz	L4C
Ming-Tao Yang	L4D
Lily Lim	L3C
Troy E. Grabow	L3D
Edward J. Naidich	L2B
Aaron J. Capron	---- --
Christian & Barton LLPLocal	L2E
R. Braxton Hill, IV	L4E
Nichole B. Vanderslice	L3D
David B. Lacy	L2E
Henry I. Willett, III	L1E
Echelon Law Group	L1E
Tae H. Kim	L3E
Andrew Choung	L2E
Kyongtaek K. Mun	L2E
John Dubiansky	L1-- --
Robert G. Litts	---- --
Haeyong Lee	---- --
Seung Ho Lee	---- --
Patterson & Sheridan LLP	L1E
Allison H. Goddard	L3C
Carlineo Spicer & KeeLocal	---- --
Daniel S. Carlineo	L1D

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Acer Inc	L4E
Acer America Corp	L4E
Fujitsu America Inc	L3D
Sierra Wireless America Inc	L2A
Casio America Inc	L1C
Sony-Ericsson Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5A
Sony Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5A
Sony Mobile Communications Ab	L5A
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications Ab	L5A
Sony Electronics Inc	L5A
Sony Corp	L5A
Panasonic Electronic Devices Corp	L5A
Panasonic Corp	L5A
Nokia Inc	L5A
Nokia Corp	L5A
Hewlett-Packard Co	L5A
Dell Inc	L5A
Apple Inc	L5A
Motorola Solutions Inc	L4A
Motorola Inc	L4A
Amazon.com	L4A
Motorola Mobility LLC	L4A
Motorola Mobility Inc	L4A
Lenovo United States Inc	L4A
Lenovo Holding Co Inc	L4A
UT Starcom Inc	L3A
Palm Inc	L3A
Personal Communications Devices LLC	L3A
Personal Communications Devices Holdings LLC	L3A
Fujitsu Ltd	L3D
Sierra Wireless Inc	L2A
General Dynamics Corp	L2A
ZTE USA Inc	L2B
ZTE Corp	L2B
Futurewei Technologies Inc	L2B
Novatel Wireless Technology Inc	L1C
Novatel Wireless Solutions Inc	L1C
Novatel Wireless Inc	L1C
Option Wireless USA Inc	---- --
Option NV	---- --
Option Inc	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Howrey LLP	L5A
Henry C. Bunsow	L5A
Victoria Q. Smith	L5E
Christopher L. Kelley	L4A
Gregory J. Commins, Jr.	L4B
Gregory S. Cordrey	L4D
Martha K. Gooding	L4D
Don F. Livornese	L4D
Andrew R. Sommer	L3B
K&L Gates	L5A
Michael J. Bettinger	L4A
Holly Hogan	L2B
K L Gates LLP	L5A
Timothy P. Walker	L4D
Eric C. Rusnak	L3B
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5A
Michael L. Brody	L4A
Jonathan E. Retsky	L4B
Peter E. Perkowski	L4C
Gail J. Standish	L4C
David P. Enzminger	L4D
David Dalke	L1E
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP	L5A
Jordan R. Jaffe	L5A
Eric Huang	L4A
Alexander Rudis	L3B
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5A
David C. Doyle	L4A
John P. Corrado	L4A
Christian G. Andreu-Von Euw	---- --
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5A
Mark D. Selwyn	L4B
Melanie D. Coates	---- --
Perkins Coie LLP	L5A
N. Thane Bauz	---- --
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5A
Michael J. Lockerby	L3B
Jones Day	L5A
Blaney Harper	L4B
Jose L. Patino	L4E
Walter D. Kelley, Jr.	L4E
Tara L. Renee Zurawski	L2E
Douglas Pearson	---- --
Greenberg Traurig LLP	L5B
E. Patrick Ellisen	L4D
James W. Soong	L3C
Alice Chu	---- --
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP	L4A
Kaiwen Tseng	L4D
Preston Burton	---- --
Covington & Burling LLP	L4A
Laura U. Muschamp	L5C
Jo Dale Carothers	L4A
David A. Garr	L4C
Leslie N. Harvey	L3B
Alston & Bird LLP	L4B
Patrick J. Flinn	L5B
Rachel M. Capoccia	L4A
Michael J. Newton	L4A
Ross R. Barton	L3A
Ryan W. Koppelman	L3B
Stacey G. White	L3B
Derek S. Neilson	L2C
Venable LLP	L4B
Michael W. Robinson	---- --
Goodwin Procter LLP	L4D
Nicole S. Cunningham	L5A
Steven A. Moore	L4A
Kurt M. Kjelland	L4B
David E. Kleinfeld	L4C
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP	L3A
Amanda R. Johnson	L3B
David C. Vondle	L3C
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L3A
John M. Jackson	L5A
Robert P. Latham	L4A
Nixon Peabody LLP	L3A
Robert E. Krebs	L4A
Christopher L. Ogden	L3A
Ronald F. Lopez	L3A
Jennifer Hayes	L2B
Sushila Chanana	L2C
Benjamin T. Hickman	---- --
McGuirewoods LLP	L3B
David E. Finkelson	L4A
Caitlin Lhommedieu	L4A
Robert M. Tyler	L4B
Brian C. Riopelle	L4D
Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP	L3B
David W. Hansen	L5C
Ashish Nagdev	L1C
Warren T. Allen, II	---- --
GibbonsLocal	L3C
Thomas R. Desimone	L2B
Frank A. Bruno	L1B
Shaw Keller LLPLocal	L3D
Kevin P. B. Johnson	---- --
Eric M. Acker	---- --
Klarquist Sparkman LLP	L2A
Jeffrey S. Love	L4A
Spotts FainLocal	L2A
Dana D. McDaniel	L4A
Edward E. Bagnell, Jr.	L2A
Spoots FainLocal	L2A
Robert J. Barrett	---- --
Craig C ReillyLocal	L2B
Craig C. Reilly	L4A
Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky & Popeo	L2D
Howard N. Wisnia	L4A
Amster Rothstein & Ebenstein	L2D
Abraham Kasdan	L4C
Joseph M. Casino	L4D
Daniel S. Ebenstein	L4D
David A. Boag	L3A
Heller Ehrman LLP	L2D
Robert T. Haslam	L4A
Michael M. Markman	L4B
Leclair Ryan	L2E
Megan S. Ben'Ary	---- --
Theodora Oringher Miller & RichmanLocal	L1B
David S. Richman	---- --
Patricia S. Riordan	---- --
Nick J. G. Sanchez	---- --
Procopio Cory Hargreaves Savitch LLP	L1E
Francis L. Tobin	---- --
Walsh Colucci Lubeley Emrich & WalshLocal	---- --
Eugene A. Burcher	L2C
Mulvaney Kahan & Barry LLPLocal	---- --
Patrick L. Prindle	---- --