DCT

3:09-cv-05422

Balthaser Online Inc v. Art Star Design LLC

General

Filed

11/20/09

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

SourcePACER

CourtN.D. California

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Richard G. Seeborg	03/19/10 - 03/30/11	39%
Jeremy D. Fogel	12/16/09 - 03/19/10	46%
David Folsom	11/21/08 - 12/16/09	40%

MagistratePaul S. Grewal, Patricia V. Trumbull

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Balthaser Online Inc NPE	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
McKool Smith	L5A
John F. Garvish, II	L5E
Samuel F. Baxter	L4A
Kristi J. Thomas	L3A
Dickstein Shapiro LLP	L4A
Peter Lambrianakos	L5A
Bryan N. Dematteo	L5A
Lawrence R. Laporte	L5B
Lawrence C. Drucker	L5B
Alfred R. Fabricant	L5D
Cindy Yang	L5E
Dawn R. Albert	L4C
Robert G. Gingher	L4E

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Electronic Arts Inc	L4A
Nike Inc	L3A
Puma North America Inc	L2A
Scripps Networks LLC	L2B
Imeem Inc	L2B
Various Inc	L1A
Global Alphabet Inc	L1D
FriendFinder Networks Inc	L1D
Capcom U S A Inc	L1D
Network Solutions LLC	L1E
Ebaum S World Inc	---- --
Swatchbox Technologies Inc	---- --
Big Jump Media Inc	---- --
Insider Guides Inc	---- --
Friendster Inc	---- --
Live Journal Inc	---- --
Knot Inc	---- --
Hookumu Inc	---- --
Hi5 Networks Inc	---- --
Gaia Interactive Inc	---- --
Freewebs Inc	---- --
Cyworld Inc	---- --
Ning Inc	---- --
Meredith Corp	L2B

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5A
Jack W. Hill	L5A
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5A
Richard S. Meyer	L5D
Townsend Townsend Crew LLP	L5A
Theodore T. Herhold	L4D
Andrew T. Oliver	L3A
Justin T. Darrow	---- --
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5A
John M. Hintz	L5A
Martin E. Gilmore	L5B
Paul B. Keller	L4A
Karen Koniuszy	---- --
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5E
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5E
S. Calvin Capshaw	L5E
Nancy C. Abernathy	L5E
Heartfield Law FirmLocal	L4A
J. Thad Heartfield	L5A
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L4A
Colin T. Kemp	L4B
Vernon H. Granneman	---- --
Banner & Witcoff LTD	L4B
Timothy C. Meece	L4A
Thomas K. Pratt	L4A
Christopher J. Renk	L4B
Michael J. Harris	L3E
Goodwin Procter LLP	L4D
Rebecca L. Unruh	L4B
Cooley LLP	L4E
Timothy S. Teter	L4E
Iain R. Cunningham	L3C
Lowell D. Mead	L3D
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L3A
John M. Jackson	L3A
Ramey & FlockLocal	L3A
Eric H. Findlay	L5A
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP	L3A
David R. Clonts	L4D
Sanford E. Warren, Jr.	L4E
Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP	L3E
Sarah E. Piepmeier	L5A
Wayne M. Barsky	L5E
Alison Watkins	L4A
David A. Segal	L4B
Julie M. Zankel	---- --
Dergosits & Noah LLPLocal	L2B
Michael E. Dergosits	L3C
Fenwick & West LLP	L2B
Ryan J. Marton	L5A
Darryl M. Woo	L4C
Jeffrey V. Lasker	L4D
Michael J. Sacksteder	L4E
Candace J. Morey	L3D
Hayes Boone LLP	L2B
John R. Emerson	L4A
Patterson & Sheridan LLP	L1B
Jerry R. Selinger	L5C
Timothy G. Ackermann	---- --
Monique Raub	---- --
Brown Rudnick LLP	L1B
Edward J. Naughton	L5A
Matthew P. Sgro	---- --
LYNN Tillotson Pinker & Cox LLPLocal	L1C
John T. Cox, III	---- --
Christopher J. Akin	---- --
Call & JensenLocal	L1C
David R. Sugden	---- --
James B. Hardin	---- --
Rothken Law FirmLocal	L1-- --
Ira P. Rothken	L1-- --
James MillsLocal	---- --
James Mills	---- --
Riney Palter PLLC	---- --
John T. Palter	---- --
Kimberly J. Sims	---- --
Schiffer Odom Hicks & Johnson PLLCLocal	---- --
Logan E. Johnson	---- --
Rush Law Group	---- --
Stephen K. Rush	---- --
MBV Law LLPLocal	---- --
L. Peter Ryan	---- --