DCT

8:09-cv-00328

Allergan Inc v. Athena Cosmetics Inc

General

Filed

03/16/09

Cause of ActionWillful Patent Infringement

SectorBiotech

Status

Closed (05/14/10)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
James V. Selna	--	45%

Plaintiff

Party

Attorney

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Athena Cosmetics Inc	---- --
Nutra-Luxe MD LLC	L1D
Stella Intl LLC	---- --
Skin Research Laboratories Inc	---- --
Rocasuba Inc	---- --
Product Innovations LLC	---- --
Pharma Tech Intl Inc	---- --
Peter Thomas Roth Labs LLC	---- --
Peter Thomas Roth Inc	---- --
Metics LLC	---- --
Lifetech Resources LLC	---- --
Cosmetic Alchemy LLC	---- --
Northwest Cosmetic Laboratories LLC	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Merchant & Gould	L3B
Karen D. McDaniel	L4C
Elizabeth A. Zidones	---- --
Graves & Shaw LLP	L3B
Philip J. Graves	L5C
James Woo Ahn	L4D
Fredricka Ung	L4E
John R. Walton	L3D
Pablo D. Arredondo	L1D
Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP	L2C
Stephen P. Benson	L5A
Martin S. Masar, III	L5C
Robert B. Breisblatt	L4A
Breighanne A. Eggert	L4B
Kristin L. Holland	L4D
Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky & Popeo	L2E
Bryan J. Sinclair	L5A
Matthew C. Bernstein	L5C
Brad M. Scheller	L5C
John E. Giust	L5C
Weiss & Moy	L1D
Jeffrey L. Weiss	L5E
Towle Denison Smith & Maniscalco LLPLocal	L1-- --
Amanda R. Washton	L1-- --
Martin C. Washton	---- --