CAFC

18-1360

IPS Group v. Duncan Solutions

General

Filed12/29/17

Appeal FromS.D. California

Originating Case3:15-cv-01526

Decision01/31/19

Appeal Outcome--

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Alan D. Lourie	1000+	77%	31%
Timothy B. Dyk	1000+	76%	41%
Richard G. Taranto	700+	72%	23%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Ips Group Inc	---- --
Duncan Parking Technologies Inc	L1D

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati	L4D
Michael Rosato	L3B
Richard Torczon	L2E
Christopher D. Mays	---- --
Adam W. Burrowbridge	---- --
Matthew A. Argenti	---- --
Douglas H. Carsten	---- --
Nathaniel R. Scharn	---- --
James P. Healy Stephens	---- --
Hunton & Williams LLP	L4D
Daniel G. Vivarelli, Jr.	---- --
Joshua M. Kalb	---- --
Steven L. Wood	---- --
Stuart A. Raphael	---- --

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Duncan Solutions Inc	L1D
Civicsmart Inc	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati	L4D
Michael Rosato	L3B
Richard Torczon	L2E
Christopher D. Mays	---- --
Adam W. Burrowbridge	---- --
Matthew A. Argenti	---- --
Douglas H. Carsten	---- --
Nathaniel R. Scharn	---- --
James P. Healy Stephens	---- --
Hunton & Williams LLP	L4D
Daniel G. Vivarelli, Jr.	---- --
Joshua M. Kalb	---- --
Steven L. Wood	---- --
Stuart A. Raphael	---- --