CAFC

17-1036

Nalco v. Winyah Refined Coal

General

Filed10/13/16

Originating Case1:14-cv-02510

Decision02/27/18

Appeal Outcome--

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Kimberly Ann Moore	800+	71%	36%
Alvin A. Schall	400+	68%	44%
Kathleen M. O'Malley	600+	71%	32%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Nalco Co	L1D

Attorney

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Winyah Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Walter Scott Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Wagner Coaltech LLC	---- --
Thomas Hill Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Refined Fuels of Illinois LLC	---- --
Mansfield Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Louisa Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Joppa Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Jefferies Refined Coal LLC	---- --
George Neal Refined Coal LLC	---- --
George Neal North Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Gallagher Clean Energy LLC	---- --
FRM Virginia Fuels LLC	---- --
FRM Trona Fuels LLC	---- --
Cross Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Coronado Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Cope Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Chem-Mod LLC	---- --
Canadys Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Brandon Shores Coaltech LLC	---- --
Belle River Fuels Co LLC	---- --
Bedford Mix LLC	---- --
Arthur J Gallagher & Co	---- --
Ajg Iowa Refined Coal LLC	---- --
Ajg Coal Inc	---- --

Attorney