CAFC

16-1309

Technology Properties Ltd v. Samsung Electronic Co Ltd

General

Filed12/11/15

Appeal FromN.D. California

Originating Case3:12-cv-03877

Decision03/03/17

Appeal OutcomeAppellant

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Kimberly Ann Moore	700+	72%	37%
Evan J. Wallach	500+	77%	32%
Raymond T. Chen	300+	75%	36%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Technology Properties Ltd NPE	L2C
Phoenix Digital Solutions LLC NPE	L1B
Patriot Scientific Corp NPE	L1B

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Nelson Bumgardner Albritton	L1C
Thomas C. Cecil	---- --
Edward R. Nelson, III	---- --
Brent N. Bumgardner	---- --
Barry Bumgardner	---- --
Greenspoon Marder PA	L1D
Robert P. Greenspoon	L3D
Travis Campbell	---- --
Silicon Valley Law Group	---- --
William L. Bretschneider	---- --
Noonan Lance Boyer & Banach LLP	---- --
Charles T. Hoge	---- --

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Samsung Electronic Co Ltd	L5D
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5D
LG Electronics USA Inc	L4A
LG Electronics	L4A
Nintendo Of America Inc	L4B
Nintendo Co Ltd	L4B
ZTE USA Inc	L3D
ZTE Corp	L3D
Huawei Technologies USA Inc	L2E
Huawei Technologies Co Ltd	L2E
Huawei Device USA Inc	L2E
Huawei Device Co Ltd	L2E
Futurewei Technologies Inc	L2E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Fish & Richardson	L5C
Christian Chu	---- --
Scott A. Elengold	---- --
McDermott Will & Emery LLP	L3A
Charles M. McMahon	L2D
Hersh H. Mehta	---- --
Cooley LLP	L3B
Stephen R. Smith	L3C
Matthew J. Brigham	---- --
DLA Piper US LLP	L3C
Mark Fowler	L2E
Stanley J. Panikowski	L1B
Erik Fuehrer	---- --
Robert Williams	---- --
James M. Heintz	---- --
Aaron Wainscoat	---- --
Steptoe & Johnson LLP	L2E
Timothy C. Bickham	---- --