CAFC

14-1825

Personalized Media Communications v. EchoStar

General

Filed09/16/14

Appeal FromE.D. Texas

Originating Case2:08-cv-00070

Decision12/22/15

Appeal OutcomeAppellant

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Jimmie V. Reyna	400+	71%	31%
Haldane R. Mayer	300+	67%	42%
Raymond T. Chen	200+	75%	41%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
EchoStar Corp	L3B
TVG-PMC Inc NPE	L3B
Rovi Guides Inc NPE	L3B

Attorney

Name	Ratings
McKool Smith	L4E
Joel L. Thollander	L3E
Roderick G. Dorman	L2E
Marc Morris	---- --
Stris Maher LLP	---- --
Daniel L. Geyser	---- --

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Personalized Media Communications LLC NPE	L2E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Goodwin Procter LLP	L5C
Arun Subramanian	L1B
Stephen Schreiner	---- --
Susman Godfrey LLP	L1E
Daniel J. Shih	L2D
Stephen D. Susman	---- --
Chanler A. Langham	---- --