CAFC

13-1092

Realtime Data v. Morgan Stanley

General

Filed12/05/12

Originating Case1:11-cv-06696

Decision01/27/14

Appeal OutcomeAppellee

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Alan D. Lourie	500+	65%	35%
Haldane R. Mayer	300+	64%	39%
Evan J. Wallach	100+	73%	32%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Realtime Data LLC NPE	L1D

Attorney

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Morgan Stanley & Co Inc	---- --
Morgan Stanley	---- --
Securities Industry Automation Corp	L4B
NYSE MKT LLC	L4B
NYSE Euronext Inc	L4B
NYSE Arca Inc	L4B
Interactive Data Corp	L4B
HSBC Securities USA Inc	L3D
HSBC Bank USA NA	L3D
Nasdaq OMX PHLX Inc	L2C
Nasdaq OMX Group Inc	L2C
Intl Securities Exchange LLC	L2C
New York Mercantile Exchange Inc	L1C
CME Group Inc	L1C
Board Of Trade Of City Of Chicago Inc	L1C
Thomson Reuters Corp	L1D
Options Price Reporting Authority	---- --
JPMorgan Chase & Co	---- --
JP Morgan Clearing Corp	---- --
Goldman Sachs Group Inc	---- --
Goldman Sachs Execution & Clearing LP	---- --
Goldman Sachs & Co LLC	---- --
Factset Research Systems Inc	---- --
Credit Suisse Securities USA LLC	---- --
Credit Suisse Holdings USA Inc	---- --
BNY Convergex Group LLC	---- --
BNY Convergex Execution Solutions LLC	---- --
Bloomberg LP	---- --
BATS Trading Inc	---- --

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5A
William F. Lee	L5A
Gregory H. Lantier	L4A
Kevin S. Prussia	L1C
Monica Grewal	---- --
Mark G. Matuschak	---- --
Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP	L2C
John M. Dimatteo	L4C
Irell & Manella LLP	L2C
Benjamin W. Hattenbach	---- --
Arka D. Chatterjee	---- --
Vinson & Elkins LLP	L1B
Constance S. Huttner	---- --
Stephanie Donahue	---- --
David J. Tobin	---- --
Syed K. Fareed	---- --
Robinson & Cole LLP	---- --
Brian E. Moran	---- --