CAFC

12-1085

Checkpoint Systems v. All Tag Security

General

Filed11/30/11

Appeal FromE.D. Pennsylvania

Originating Case2:01-cv-02223

Decision09/04/14

Appeal OutcomeAppellant

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Pauline Newman	500+	64%	33%
Alan D. Lourie	600+	69%	35%
Alvin A. Schall	300+	60%	45%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Checkpoint Systems Inc	L3B

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Honigman Miller Schwartz Cohn LLP	L1B
Robert J. Palmersheim	L3A
Steven A. Weiss	---- --
Lesley G. Smith	---- --
Schnader Harrison Segal & Lewis LLP	---- --
Thomas W. Hazlett	---- --
Dennis R. Suplee	---- --

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
All-Tag Security SA	L2E
All-Tag Security Americas Inc	L2E
Sensormatic Electronics Corp	L4E
Kobe Properties SARL	L1E

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Reed Smith LLP	L3E
Tracy Z. Quinn	L2C
Troutman Sanders LLP	L2C
Erik N. Videlock	---- --
M. Kelly Tillery	---- --
Charles S. Marion	---- --
Breiner & Breiner	L1D
Theodore A. Breiner	L2D